Become an Insider!
Sign-Up

Celebrate Christmas:

Overall Popularity

1.
A Christmas Prayer 65.6% · 219 first-place votes
2.
Timeless Tidings of Joy 48.9% · 144 first-place votes
3.
Have We Met This Christmas? 33.4% · 69 first-place votes
4.
A Wisconsin Christmas Pie 33.1% · 84 first-place votes
5.
A Royal Icing Christmas 18% · 10 first-place votes

First-Choice Favorites

1.
A Christmas Prayer 31.6% · 219 first-place votes
2.
Timeless Tidings of Joy 20.7% · 144 first-place votes
3.
A Wisconsin Christmas Pie 12.1% · 84 first-place votes
4.
Have We Met This Christmas? 9.9% · 69 first-place votes
5.
Christmas at Mistletoe Manor 6.5% · 45 first-place votes

Most Consistently Ranked High

1.
A Christmas Prayer 71.2% · 494 top-3 appearances
2.
Timeless Tidings of Joy 46% · 319 top-3 appearances
3.
Have We Met This Christmas? 36.5% · 253 top-3 appearances
4.
A Wisconsin Christmas Pie 33.4% · 232 top-3 appearances
5.
A Royal Icing Christmas 19.6% · 136 top-3 appearances
6.
Chasing Christmas 16.4% · 114 top-3 appearances
7.
Christmas at Mistletoe Manor 15.3% · 106 top-3 appearances
8.
Christmas in Midnight Clear 14.4% · 100 top-3 appearances
9.
The Christmas Spark 11.2% · 78 top-3 appearances
10.
Cranberries and Carols 8.1% · 56 top-3 appearances